Insights

The Promise of Value in Primary Care

Hardly a day goes by without primary care in the news, whether it’s a new payment model, a new assessment of the primary care crisis, or the beginning or end of another business venture. The value of primary care is clear: Robust evidence from many settings shows that increased engagement with primary care improves health outcomes and patient experience, and that increased investment in and access to primary care lowers total health care costs.

May 17, 2024

Quality Improvement

Hardly a day goes by without primary care in the news, whether it’s a new payment model, a new assessment of the primary care crisis, or the beginning or end of another business venture. The value of primary care is clear: Robust evidence from many settings shows that increased engagement with primary care improves health outcomes and patient experience, and that increased investment in and access to primary care lowers total health care costs. Based on the definition of value as quality divided by cost, primary care delivers some of the highest value in health care. Yet we continue to under-resource it, to the detriment of individual patients and the system as a whole.

How did this situation happen, and how can it be fixed? The under-resourcing of primary care is grounded in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) relative value unit (RVU) system, which undervalues cognitive specialties relative to procedural ones. Combined with escalating overhead costs, this creates a relentless drive for increased volume of patient visits — not to boost provider take-home pay, but just to keep clinics afloat. At the same time, primary care providers are now expected to play a large population health role (tracking quality results, doing outreach, closing gaps) without adequate compensation for the time this work requires, or the resources to hire staff to perform these duties. Time spent in charting and administrative work is often more than the time spent in patient care (by a 2-1 ratio, according to one study).

Value-based purchasing (VBP), used in primary care for decades, should alleviate some of this strain. However, for many primary care providers, the promise of value-based care to “drive value, not volume” has been an empty one; value-based incentives have not been sufficient to enable providers to see fewer patients, so they are pressured to deliver both more quality and more volume than ever.

Considering “value” from a population health perspective, delivery models have emerged that call for physicians to orchestrate and direct the care provided by a large team while interacting only with particularly sick or complex patients. This is an efficient approach to extending the reach of a limited provider population, and if executed well, it can yield good clinical outcomes (and associated VBP payments). However, it may not be satisfying to doctors who entered primary care with a desire to form deep, longitudinal connections to their patients, nor to patients seeking the benefits of a close therapeutic relationship with a provider who understands their history, needs and values.

A patient perspective on value underlies the opposite end of the spectrum: concierge and direct primary care (DPC) practices. Through a private pay subscription with monthly or yearly rates (which can vary broadly from around $100 a month to over $50K a year), patients get intensive access to a provider with a very small panel. These models raise concerning questions for equity and may divert providers from less resourced populations who often have the highest needs. However, the growth in this arena indicates many people see enough value in a provider’s time to be willing to pay for access. Similarly, some employers, seeing the value of effective primary care through a lens of improving absenteeism, presenteeism, productivity and loyalty, as well as lowered total costs of care, are directly funding primary care access, either through dedicated on-site clinics or by paying subscription fees.

Big business has joined the fray: A year ago, after the shuttering of Haven, their failed joint effort with Berkshire Hathaway and JPMorgan Chase, Amazon spent $3.9B to acquire One Medical, a subscription service aimed at healthy young people and emphasizing convenience. Results so far have been mixed; given One Medical’s limited bricks-and-mortar footprint, some patients have access only to online services, and patients and staff have expressed concerns about increased patient volume, shorter visits and lowered service levels. Another large-business entrant, Walmart, after establishing clinics providing primary and urgent care alongside its superstores, recently announced that all 51 health care centers in six states would close, as they determined it was “not a sustainable business model.” A common challenge seems to be a lack of clarity in defining value — to succeed, it must be clear what needs are being met by these practices and how those translate into sustainable financing of a functional delivery model.

Advanced value-based approaches have the potential to create meaningful improvement and sustainability across a variety of practice types, but only if they incorporate adequate investment to pull providers out of the value-plus-volume quagmire. The CMS Innovation Center, building on prior work such as Comprehensive Primary Care (CPC) and CPC Plus, has recently created the Making Care Primary (MCP) model. Piloting in eight states, MCP includes foundational payments to support transformation work for providers early in the process as well as supports for more advanced practices with a monthly payment for attributed patients and an additional quality payment based on outcomes. Of note, the quality-based payments within this model are much more substantial than those of many previous approaches, with the potential to achieve a true increase in primary care investment and a “value over volume” shift.

Combined with advances in AI and other technologies to reduce provider burden in documentation and other low-value tasks, these approaches have the potential to return primary care to a state in which providers find not just sustainability but joy and fulfillment: where volume truly doesn’t dominate other factors, quality efforts are adequately resourced and connections with patients are moved from the fringes back to the center of the work. Currently, there is an inadequate supply of primary care providers to fulfill access needs even if supportive models were in place, but recruiting and retaining providers to primary care will get much easier over time if the life and work are sustainable, and the workforce will gradually re-emerge.

In the long term, there are likely many delivery models that will work for different patients and providers — some emphasizing a large team, others a deeper connection to individuals and undoubtedly more that are not yet imagined. But for primary care to thrive, there needs to be an adequate understanding of the value it provides across all dimensions: to individual patients, employers, government, population health, total health care costs and others. By harnessing that value, it becomes possible to resource and support a thriving primary care culture that serves both its providers and its patients well.

From solo clinicians to large systems, Comagine Health helps primary care practices achieve a better balance of value and volume. Contact us to discuss how we can support you.

Author / Contributor(s)

Smiling woman with shoulder-length brown hair wearing a black blazer

Emily R. Transue

MD, MHA, FACP

Chief Clinical Officer

Recent Insights

The Family Side of Substance Use and Recovery: Hope, Healing and Resources During National Recovery Month

The Medicaid Cliff: Collaboration Is Key to Protecting Medicaid Access

What Community Organizing Can Teach Us About Health System Transformation